Research Article

Artificial Intelligence in Judicial Decision-Making: Assessing the Legal, Ethical, and Institutional Implications of Machine Learning-Based Decision Support Systems in U.S. Courts

Authors

  • Mohammed Nazmul Islam Miah Management Sciences and Quantitative Methods, Gannon University, Erie, PA, USA
  • MD Joshim Uddin Master’s of Law, ASA University of Bangladesh
  • Manohar Kakumani Master of Science in Computer and Information Science, Gannon University, Erie, PA, USA

Abstract

The increasing adoption of artificial intelligence in the criminal justice system has created opportunities to improve judicial information processing, predictive assessment, and administrative efficiency, while raising concerns regarding fairness, transparency, and institutional accountability. This study examines the legal, ethical, and institutional implications of machine learning-based decision-support systems in U.S. courts, with particular attention to pretrial risk assessment, sentencing support, case outcome prediction, legal information retrieval, and judicial document classification. The research adopts a structured secondary-research design and a comparative analytical framework to evaluate the potential benefits, limitations, and governance requirements associated with these applications. The findings indicate that machine learning can support judicial administration by improving information retrieval, identifying patterns in large collections of legal records, facilitating document classification, and promoting consistency in selected analytical tasks. However, algorithmic predictions may reproduce historical inequalities, generate discriminatory outcomes, obscure the reasoning underlying judicial recommendations, and create opportunities for excessive reliance on automated assessments. These concerns are particularly consequential when algorithmic outputs influence decisions affecting individual liberty and legal rights. The study further establishes that predictive performance alone is insufficient to demonstrate the suitability of machine learning for judicial decision-making. Responsible adoption requires meaningful judicial oversight, procedural transparency, independent auditing, representative data, fairness assessment, explainability, contestability, and continuous institutional monitoring. The study concludes that machine learning can contribute to the effectiveness of U.S. courts when deployed within a governance framework that preserves due process, judicial independence, individual rights, and institutional accountability.

Article information

Journal

Frontiers in Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence

Volume (Issue)

5 (12)

Pages

23-33

Published

2026-11-18

How to Cite

Miah, M. N. I., Uddin, M. J., & Kakumani, M. (2026). Artificial Intelligence in Judicial Decision-Making: Assessing the Legal, Ethical, and Institutional Implications of Machine Learning-Based Decision Support Systems in U.S. Courts. Frontiers in Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence, 5(12), 23-33. https://doi.org/10.32996/fcsai.2026.5.12.3

Downloads

Views

0

Downloads

0

Keywords:

Artificial intelligence, machine learning, judicial decision-making, algorithmic decision-making, U.S. courts, algorithmic bias, legal technology, risk assessment