The Effect of Reflective Journal Writing on Moroccan EFL Master Students’ Reflective Thinking: A Mixed Methods Study

Abstract

Reflective thinking is one of the transferable skills necessary for academic and professional success. Therefore, stimulating English as a foreign language (EFL) students’ reflective skills is undoubtedly important. Reflective journal writing is a pedagogical strategy proposed to help students build their reflective potential. Although previous research investigated the effect of this strategy on the development of students’ reflective skills, there are inconsistent conclusions regarding its effectiveness. Also, limited research has investigated this issue in relation to EFL students in the Moroccan context, specifically in higher education. The aim of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of reflective journal writing in improving EFL master students reflective thinking. A convergent mixed methods approach associated with a quasi-experimental design was adopted. To collect quantitative and qualitative data, Kember, Leung, et al (2000) Reflective Thinking Questionnaire and reflective journal writing were used, respectively. A purposive sample of 69 EFL master students, including two intact groups, took part in the study. They were randomly assigned to experimental (n = 39) and control groups (n = 30). Quantitative results and qualitative findings revealed that the experimental group, after using reflective journals, has significantly developed reflective thinking compared to the control group. Also, a statistically significant change over time in the experimental group level of reflective thinking was observed. As it can be inferred, reflective journal writing is an effective strategy which could be used to help EFL students engage in a reflective reasoning. Accordingly, the results of this study encourage the formalization of reflective practice as a didactic approach to stimulate EFL students’ reflective thinking at the tertiary level.